Build a Board That Fundraises With You

Welcome back to The Bridge Brief. We've spent the last few issues on funding: community engagement, relational funders and a diversified revenue mix. All of that work gets much lighter when you're not carrying it alone. So today I want to talk about the people who are supposed to be carrying it with you: your board.

If you're an executive director, I suspect you've felt this at least once. You walk out of a board meeting where everyone nodded through the reports, approved the budget and agreed that fundraising is important, and then you go back to doing nearly all of it yourself.

That isn't a character flaw on anyone's part. In my experience, a disengaged board is almost always a design problem. People were recruited without clear expectations, handed a binder and left to figure out the rest. Most board members join because they care about the mission, not because they love asking for money. Many feel unsure or unprepared, and nobody has ever shown them what fundraising looks like beyond "make the ask." The good news is that design problems can be fixed.

Recruit for what you need, not just who you know

Too many boards are filled by asking, "Who do we know who might say yes?" A better question is, "What does our organization need over the next few years, and who can help us get there?" Take stock of the skills, perspectives and relationships already around the table, and name the gaps: finance experience, ties to local businesses, lived experience of the issue you work on, or connections to a community you haven't reached yet. Then recruit the way you'd cultivate a donor. Get to know prospective members, invite them to see your work and let the relationship develop before you ask.

Set expectations before anyone says yes

This is the single change I see make the biggest difference. Put it in writing before a candidate accepts. A simple board member agreement might cover attending meetings and serving on a committee, making a personal gift at a level that is meaningful to them, taking part in fundraising in specific, agreed-upon ways, and acting as an ambassador in their own networks.

Many organizations ask every board member to give each year, at whatever level is meaningful for that person. It isn't about the amount. It's about being able to tell funders that everyone at the leadership table is invested. When expectations are clear from the start, no one feels ambushed later, and honest conversations get much easier.

Redefine fundraising so everyone has a role

Fundraising is far more than asking for a check. It's a cycle: identifying supporters, building relationships, making the ask, and thanking and staying connected afterward. Every board member can play a part somewhere in that cycle.

Some will be comfortable making asks. Others can open doors in their networks, host a small gathering, share your story online or write thank-you notes. Thank-you calls are often a favorite. Calling a donor just to say thank you, with no ask attached, is one of the most enjoyable and confidence-building things a new board member can do. Invite each member to choose a few activities that fit their strengths, and write them into a simple annual plan. Small, specific commitments happen. Vague promises to "help with fundraising" usually don't.

Make meetings worth showing up for

If your board meetings are mostly reports, your board will act like an audience. If they involve real decisions and real conversation, your board will act like partners. Send reports ahead of time so the meeting can go to discussion. Put one strategic question on every agenda. Bring the mission into the room with a short story from a staff member or participant. And make fundraising a standing agenda item, with time to share progress, celebrate wins and practice talking about your work. People get comfortable with fundraising when they talk about it regularly, not only when the budget is tight.

Support, thank and follow through

An engaged board needs care, just like your donors do. Give new members a real orientation on your programs, finances and fundraising plan, and pair them with experienced members when you can. Offer simple tools: a short talking points sheet, a few stories and a list of upcoming events they can invite people to. Check in with each member once or twice a year, and celebrate their contributions out loud. When someone isn't engaged, ask them about it directly and kindly. Sometimes life has changed, and a different role or a graceful step back is the right answer for everyone.

Engagement doesn't happen on its own. It has to be built, the same way you'd build any program. And it applies just as much to the advisory boards and councils that guide healthcare organizations and university programs.

A strong board is one of the first things funders look for, so take a few minutes with our free Grant Readiness Checklist to see where your organization stands. If you want support recruiting, preparing or re-energizing your board, explore our board development services or book a free 30-minute consult.

If you'd like to talk through where your board stands today and what it could become, we'd love to have that conversation.

With gratitude,

Luminary Bridge Consulting

Previous
Previous

Before You Apply: What Funders Really Look For

Next
Next

Shine a Light on Every Funding Stream